In 2025, many marginalized groups are experiencing increased discrimination in policy, rhetoric and access to resources. Opinions on immigration are varied and often polarize debates, with some legislators calling for implementation of policy to cooperate with and assist the federal government in locating and detaining undocumented immigrants and others scrambling to draft and pass policies that refuse and resist federal deportation operations in their communities. While immigration has been a major topic of division among citizens and lawmakers in different eras in the United States, Donald Trump and his administration have created the most aggressive anti-immigration policy in the nation’s history. Primary reasons for the tactics used to identify, detain and deport undocumented (and also documented) immigrants have been cited as alleged criminality, espionage, negative tax influence, disproportionate resource consumption and employment acquisition of immigrants in the United States (EO 14159, 2025).
To consider any of these assertions to be truthful, is to believe harmful misinformation. It’s critical to identify myths and prioritize facts to the contrary. Though there are beliefs that immigrants deprive non-immigrants of job opportunities, they actually contribute significantly to job creation, and with over 7 million available jobs and relatively low unemployment rates, immigrants also contribute to significant need for workforces. Beliefs about immigrants contributing significant tax burden are also unfounded, with refugees and asylees alone contributing approximately $581 billion to the economy and paid over $89 billion in local and federal taxes in 2023. One of the most dangerous and popular myths about immigration is that immigrants contribute significantly to crime in America. This couldn’t be further from the truth, with research consistently finding that there is no correlation between immigration and increased crime rates and, in some instances, immigration has been shown to decrease crime rates (Immigrants Make the US Stronger, 2025).
While the above facts should be well-known and responsibly distributed, they are not as effectively distributed as they should be and the myths are established and distributed by the executive office and supportive media, social media and citizens. The cost of this reckless assertion of ignorance and aggression is felt most by the people who need to be in America for their well-being and safety and that of their loved ones as well. The rights of asylum-seekers and refugees are protected in the American constitution and the current executive orders violate these rights, as well as international laws. The capture, detainment and deportation of these particularly vulnerable individuals places them in grave and immediate danger and separates many of them from their families, despite legislative and voter support to the contrary. In an internationally infamous case in 2025, one such person was kidnapped from his home in the middle of the night and deported to El Salvador in an expedited process which ended in his placement in one of the deadliest mega-prisons in El Salvador.
Kilmar Abrego Garcia was abducted by ICE agents from his home the night of March 12, 2025, in response to an accusation that he is a member of the El Salvadoran gang, MS-13. This allegation is based on a confidential informant who claimed Abrego Garcia had been a member of the gang in New York. Abrego Garcia has never lived in New York, and he has received no criminal convictions in any country. He was granted protections from deportation by an immigration judge based on the likelihood that he could be harmed in El Salvador. The Department of Justice (DOJ) has admitted that Abrego Garcia was deported by mistake, but the White House has made many statements against Mr. Abrego Garcia that do not reflect any admittance of error. An ongoing struggle between the executive and judicial branches of government have led to Mr. Abrego Garcia being moved from the mega-prison, Centro de Confinamiento del Terrorismo (CECOT), to a detention center in Santa Ana, El Salvador, but it is unclear whether Abrego Garcia will ever be released from custody in El Salvador and the White House continues to insist that he is an active member of MS-13, and a terrorism threat to the United States. The White House has also made statements that Kilmar Abrego Garcia will never live in the United States again and that he will be immediately deported if he ever returns, despite an order by the Supreme Court that DOJ facilitate his return. His wife and three children are American citizens and may never see their loved one again if he is not allowed to return to the United States (Habeshian, 2025).
Kilmar Abrego Garcia was one of many immigrants with protected status who are under threat, both in their countries of origin and in the United States, despite having legal protections for their well-being. Many of them, like Abrego Garcia are law-abiding, have not been convicted of any crimes, and uphold the responsibilities of their immigration status dutifully. It is our responsibility, as a country which has written into the fabric of its policies a determination and dedication to protecting those who come here seeking safety and opportunity, to protect them in their time of need. The executive orders of the White House do not reflect the values of the majority and they must be challenged at each level of authority and by every person who is an ally to immigrants. State and local arresting agencies have been receiving messages to cooperate with and assist ICE in the capture and detainment of people who are suspected to be in the country illegally. They have been urged and even ordered to accommodate ICE operations against immigrants by providing and employing their resources to said operations.
Ideally, the United States would unanimously establish an intention, code and implementation of law which honors the rights and opportunities of all immigrants, but the actions of Mr. Trump and his supporters do not inspire confidence that this is the case or will be any time during this presidency. While the current actions against immigrants and international cooperation are extreme in comparison, there have been other government actions against immigrants in the United States at the executive and judicial levels. It is crucial that state, municipal and local governments establish official and permanent status as sanctuary cities by setting permanent jurisdiction which limits cooperation with federal immigration authorities and supply of personnel or resources to support operations by federal immigration authorities. This way, human beings stand a greater chance of remaining safely and securely in their homes, with their loved ones, and their rights and dignity intact and protected.
Many immigrants are facing persecution in the United States, both by the government which has sworn to defend them and by citizens who have been emboldened by the actions of a fascist occupation of the federal government. It is the duty of the people to hold local, state, federal, judicial and executive powers accountable for the values they claim to embody and enforce. It is the duty of the people to establish, in written and enforced policy and in community action, robust and thorough safeguards for immigrants in the United States. America benefits from the people who come here to live their lives in safety and to contribute to the success and strength of their new home. This country belongs to the people and very few who live here, legally or otherwise, got here without someone immigrating here before them or with them in tow. It is time to ensure that what is happening in this country right now never happens in the United States ever again. If America truly is an example for the rest of the world to follow, it stands to reason that the rest of the world ought to feel safe and welcome on American soil.
References
Combatting Disinformation: Immigrants Make the U.S. Stronger. (2025, May 10). Global Refuge. https://www.globalrefuge.org/get-involved/advocate-with-us/disinformation/EO
Habeshian, S. (2025, April 30). Timeline: The case of a Maryland man mistakenly deported to El Salvador. Axios Politics & Policy. https://www.axios.com/2025/04/14/timeline-kilmar- abrego-garcia-deported-caseMishell, Z. (2025, March 3). Trump’s Executive Orders: What Do They Mean and How We Can Fight Back. Interfaith Alliance Achieving Democracy Together. https://www.interfaithalliance.org/post/trumps-executive-orders
Rose, J. (2025, April 11). Maryland judge again asks government to return man wrongly deported to El Salvador. NPR. https://www.npr.org/2025/04/11/nx-s1-5361148/maryland-judge-mistaken-deportation
14159, FR Citation: 90 FR 8443. https://www.whitehouse.gov/presidential- actions/2025/01/protecting-the-american-people-against-invasion/